Practice Series
Using Generative AI in Your Practice: A Checklist for 24th Circuit Lawyers

Generative AI tools can draft a letter, summarize a deposition or suggest an argument in seconds. They can also invent a case that does not exist and cite it with complete confidence. Courts around the country have sanctioned lawyers who filed briefs citing these “hallucinated” authorities.
Two courts in our circuit have now written rules for it. The Amherst and Nelson Circuit Courts each adopted a local rule on generative AI in February and March 2026. Both require lawyers to disclose AI use in filings and in trial exhibits.
The local rules are new, but most of the underlying duties are not. Here is a checklist for using these tools responsibly.
Before you use an AI tool
- Know what the tool does with your data. Read the terms of service and privacy settings. Some tools keep what you type and use it to train future models. Putting client information into a tool like that can raise confidentiality concerns under Rule 1.6 of the Virginia Rules of Professional Conduct.
- Understand its limits. Generative AI predicts plausible text. It does not look up the law the way a citator does, unless it is built on a research database, and even then it can be wrong. The duty of competence under Rule 1.1 includes understanding the tools you use.
- Set expectations for your staff. If paralegals or assistants use AI tools on client work, you are responsible for supervising that work under Rule 5.3.
Before you file or send anything
- Read every citation yourself. Pull and read each case, statute and rule the draft cites. Confirm that it exists, says what the draft claims, and is still good law.
- Check every fact against the record. AI tools can misstate dates, names, amounts and testimony.
- Remember what your signature means. Under Virginia Code § 8.01-271.1(B), signing a pleading, motion or other paper certifies that you have read it and that, after reasonable inquiry, it is well grounded in fact and warranted by existing law or a good-faith argument for changing it. That duty is the same whether you or a tool wrote the first draft.
- Add the disclosure where it is required. In Amherst and Nelson Circuit Courts, attach the disclosure certification to any filing that generative AI helped draft, create, enhance or modify. Both courts provide a model form. In Amherst, this includes letters to the court.
Before trial or an evidentiary hearing
- Calendar the exhibit certification. In Amherst and Nelson, file the certification disclosing AI use in proposed exhibits, including demonstratives, at least ten days before the trial or hearing.
- Track how each exhibit was made. A timeline, chart, enhanced photo or animation may involve AI. Ask whoever prepared it, including vendors and experts.
Keep a record
- Note which tool you used and for what. A short note in the file makes the disclosure easy to complete accurately and helps if a question comes up later.
Practicing outside Amherst and Nelson
The disclosure requirements apply only in the courts that adopted them. The duties under Code § 8.01-271.1 and the Rules of Professional Conduct apply everywhere. Before filing in any court, check its local rules and standing orders. Our Court & Bar Resources page lists the standing orders and local rules that have been circulated to the bar.
This post is general information for our members, not legal or ethics advice. For guidance on a specific situation, consult the Virginia State Bar’s ethics hotline or your own counsel.
