Skip to main content
Lynchburg Bar Association

Court Notices

Amherst and Nelson Circuit Courts Adopt Local Rules on Generative AI

Generative AI local rules: Amherst and Nelson Circuit Courts require disclosure

Two circuit courts in the 24th Judicial Circuit have adopted local rules on the use of generative artificial intelligence. Neither court bans AI. Both require you to say when you have used it, and both remind lawyers that they remain responsible for every word they file.

  • Nelson County Circuit Court: Local Rule on Generative Artificial Intelligence, entered February 19, 2026 (Judge Michael R. Doucette). Read the Nelson rule (PDF).
  • Amherst County Circuit Court: Local Rule on Use of Artificial Intelligence, entered March 3, 2026 (Judge Jeffrey P. Bennett). Read the Amherst rule (PDF).

Both courts adopted their rules under Rule 1:15 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Virginia, and both directed their clerks to send copies to the local bar associations, including ours.

What both rules require

1. A written disclosure on anything prepared with generative AI. Attorneys and pro se litigants must include a disclosure certification at the end of, or attached to, any filing that generative AI helped draft, create, enhance or modify. That covers pleadings, motions, briefs, memoranda, sketch orders and exhibits. Each court attached a model disclosure form to its rule.

2. An exhibit certification before trial. At least ten days before any trial or evidentiary hearing, attorneys and pro se litigants must file a certification disclosing the use of generative AI in any proposed exhibits, including demonstrative exhibits.

3. Review before you file. Both rules tie the duty to review AI-assisted work to Virginia Code § 8.01-271.1(B). Under that statute, your signature certifies that you have read the paper and that, after reasonable inquiry, it is well grounded in fact and warranted by existing law or a good-faith argument for changing it. The Nelson rule puts it plainly: filings must be “hallucination-free.”

4. Sanctions. Failing to properly review AI-assisted work can lead to sanctions under both rules. Nelson points to Code § 8.01-271.1(D), Rule 1:5A and the Rules of Professional Conduct. Amherst adds that it may also lead to findings of contempt.

Where the two rules differ

Amherst Nelson
Entered March 3, 2026 February 19, 2026
Covers Any filing, pleading, motion, brief, memorandum, sketch order, letter or other document submitted to the court, with exhibits and attachments Any pleading, exhibit to a pleading, memorandum, brief, sketch order or other filing
Human oversight Expressly required for any AI use before the court Implied through the duty to review
Model certification You certify that you personally reviewed every factual claim, legal claim, citation, authority, source, argument and conclusion, and that the filing complies with Code § 8.01-271.1, Rule 1:5 and, where appropriate, the rules of professional conduct You certify that, to the best of your knowledge, the filing is well grounded in fact and warranted by existing law or a good-faith argument for changing it
Possible consequences Sanctions or findings of contempt Sanctions, including under Code § 8.01-271.1(D), Rule 1:5A and the Rules of Professional Conduct

Two practical points stand out. First, the Amherst rule reaches letters to the court, not just formal filings. Second, the Amherst model certification is the stricter of the two: it asks you to certify personal review of every citation and authority, not just your belief that the filing is sound.

What neither rule says

Neither rule defines “generative AI.” Many everyday tools now include AI features, such as legal research platforms, word processors and grammar checkers. The rules do not say which of these trigger a disclosure. If you are unsure whether your use of a tool calls for one, ask the clerk’s office or raise it with the court.

Neither rule applies outside its own court. The bar association has not received a similar rule from the courts in Lynchburg, Bedford County or Campbell County. That does not mean none exists, so check with the clerk in any court where you practice. If you learn of another AI rule in the circuit, please let us know.

Where to find these rules

Both rules are listed, with links, under Standing orders and court policies on our Court & Bar Resources page. Courts can amend local rules at any time, so confirm the current version with the clerk’s office before relying on one.

This post summarizes the courts’ rules for the convenience of our members. It is not legal advice. Read the full rules before relying on them.